| Ben Darmstadt (2013-16) | 175 wins |
| Dylan Shawver (2017-20) | 175 wins |
| J.T. Brown (2014-17) | 168 wins |
| Kevin Vough (2014-17) | 164 wins |
| Josh Breeding (2015-18) | 162 wins |
| Jake Evans (2018-21) | 162 wins |
| Stevie Mitcheff (2005-08) | 160 wins |
| Mick Burnett (2017-20) | 154 wins |
| Enrique Munguia (2018-21) | 145 wins |
| Brendon Fenton (2015-18) | 144 wins |
| Armando Torres (2011-14) | 142 wins |
| Nate Burnett (2019-22) | 135 wins |
| Jason Gott (2008-11) | 135 wins |
| Dalton McHenry (2006-09) | 135 wins |
| Matt Zuckerman (2016-19) | 132 wins |
| Paul Felton (2000-03) | 131 wins |
| James Faught (2001-04) | 124 wins |
| Nico O'Dor (2013-16) | 123 wins |
| Brendan Price (2014-17) | 122 wins |
| Kodie Egnor (2007-10) | 120 wins |
| Ryan Nelisse (2006-09) | 119 wins |
| Bryce Allison (2017-20) | 116 wins |
| Lewis Aguilar (2016-19) | 114 wins |
| Paul Sen (2002-05) | 113 wins |
| Alec Bottomlee (2000-03) | 112 wins |
| Peyton Fenton (2019-22) | 110 wins |
| Mikah Price (2013-16) | 110 wins |
| Drew Levis (2016-19) | 109 wins |
| Taylor Workman (2011-14) | 108 wins |
| Brandon Egnor (2010-13) | 105 wins |
| Colin Noel (2018-21) | 104 wins |
| Zack Goins (2006-09) | 104 wins |
| Cameron King (2014-17) | 104 wins |
| Jeff Lyons (1984-87) | 103 wins |
| Jeremiah Fitzpatrick (2000-04) | 101 wins |
| Andrew Perez (2003-04) | 172 wins (79) at Elyria HS |
| Johnny Pycraft (2005-06) | 152 wins (72) at Elyria HS |
| John McNulty (1977-78) | 143 wins (68) at Elyria HS |
| Devan Price (2011-12) | 111 wins (56) at Elyria HS |
| Danny Mitcheff (2004-05) | 132 wins (51) at Elyria HS |
| Nick Mayer (2015) | 109 wins (38) at Elyria HS |
| Conner Burrus (2021) | 123 wins (26) at EHS |
| Cameron Elam (2016) | 113 wins (14) at Elyria HS |
